An experimental and theoretical charge density study of theophylline and malonic acid cocrystallization

Hawkins, Bryson A., Du, Jonathan J., Lai, Felcia, Stanton, Stephen A., Williams, Peter A., Groundwater, Paul W., Platts, James A. ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-1008-6595, Overgaard, Jacob and Hibbs, David E. 2022. An experimental and theoretical charge density study of theophylline and malonic acid cocrystallization. RSC Advances 12 (25) , 15670. 10.1039/D1RA08389A

Preview

PDF - Published Version Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial. Download (3MB) | Preview

Abstract

The pharmaceutical agent theophylline (THEO) is primarily used as a bronchodilator and is commercially available in both tablet and liquid dosage forms. THEO is highly hygroscopic, reducing its stability, overall shelf-life, and therefore usage as a drug. THEO and dicarboxylic acid cocrystals were designed by Trask et al. in an attempt to decrease the hygroscopic behaviour of THEO; cocrystallisation of THEO with malonic acid (MA) did not improve the hygroscopic stability of THEO in simulated atmospheric humidity testing. The current study employed high-resolution X-ray crystallography, and Density Functional Theory (DFT) calculations to examine the electron density distribution (EDD) changes between the cocrystal and its individual components. The EED changes identified the reasons why the THEO:MA cocrystal did not alter the hygroscopic profile of THEO. The cocrystal was equally porous, with atomic packing factors (APF) similar to those of THEO 0.73 vs. 0.71, respectively. The THEO:MA (1) cocrystal structure is held together by an array of interactions; a heterogeneous synthon between the imidazole and a carboxylic fragment stabilising the asymmetric unit, a pyrimidine-imidazole homosynthon, and an aromatic cycle stack between two THEO moieties have been identified, providing 9.7–12.9 kJ mol−1 of stability. These factors did not change the overall relative stability of the cocrystal relative to its individual THEO and MA components, as shown by cocrystal (1) and THEO being equally stable, with calculated lattice energies within 2.5 kJ mol−1 of one other. The hydrogen bond analysis and fragmented atomic charge analysis highlighted that the formation of (1) combined both the EDD of THEO and MA with no net chemical change, suggesting that the reverse reaction — (1) back to THEO and MA — is of equal potential, ultimately producing THEO hydrate formation, in agreement with the work of Trask et al. These results highlight that a review of the EDD change associated with a chemical reaction can aid in understanding cocrystal design. In addition, they indicate that cocrystal design requires further investigation before becoming a reliable process, with particular emphasis on identifying the appropriate balance of synthon engineering, weak interactions, and packing dynamics.

Item Type:	Article
Date Type:	Published Online
Status:	Published
Schools:	Chemistry
Additional Information:	Attribution-NonCommercial 3.0 Unported (CC BY-NC 3.0)
Publisher:	Royal Society of Chemistry
ISSN:	2046-2069
Date of First Compliant Deposit:	1 July 2022
Date of Acceptance:	16 February 2022
Last Modified:	10 May 2023 16:32
URI:	https://orca.cardiff.ac.uk/id/eprint/150963

Actions (repository staff only)

Edit Item