Theorising the rainbow? The puzzle of the public-private divide

Grear, Anna ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2993-1370 2003. Theorising the rainbow? The puzzle of the public-private divide. Res Publica 9 (2) , pp. 169-194. 10.1023/A:1024125527021

Full text not available from this repository.

Abstract

Two influential approaches to conceptualising the relationship between public and private law have suggested that the distinction between them should be abandoned. The first, as exemplified by Oliver, suggests that the distinction should be abandoned in favour of fusion based on the notion of commonality. The second, as exemplified by Teubner, rejects fusion, arguing for the replacement of the distinction with a concept capturing the multi-dimensional complexity of law in multiple social contexts: `polycontexturality'. This article focuses primarily on exploring conceptual puzzles presented by Oliver's `commonality thesis', and argues for a reconceptualisation of the relationship between public and private law as multi-layered. Monolithic and rigidly binary concepts alike should be replaced by a complex set of relationships – a position broadly supportive of Teubner's. However, it is argued that the relationships between public and private law are to be seen as existing on a spectrum, or even on an overarching meta-spectrum, in which the existence of distinctive `archetypal conceptual paradigms' influence as `meta-spectrum extremities'. This presents a limited caveat to Teubner's thesis. I suggest that explicit theoretical attention to both the implications of polycontexturality and the existence of the archetypal conceptual paradigms as meta-spectrum extremities might avoid occluding important distinctions and nuances within a fusion that tends illegitimately to subsume private law within a public law paradigm. Such an analysis, I argue, could enhance the coherence of the law in complex, multi-dimensional cases at the troubled borderline between public and private law.

Item Type:	Article
Date Type:	Publication
Status:	Published
Schools:	Law
Uncontrolled Keywords:	`archetypal conceptual paradigms'; commonality; common values; fusion; meta-spectrum; polycontexturality; private law autonomies; privatisation; public/private divide
Publisher:	Kluwer
ISSN:	1356-4765
Last Modified:	05 Jan 2024 08:30
URI:	https://orca.cardiff.ac.uk/id/eprint/53191

Citation Data

Actions (repository staff only)

Edit Item